• Home
  • Blog
  • Reviews
    • Air Pumps
    • Gravel Vacuum
    • Aquarium thermometer
    • Automatic fish feeder
    • Water changer
    • Aquarium timers
  • Algae
  • Disease

Surface Agitation: Stir, Churn and Oxygenate Your Aquarium!

Last Updated on February 11, 2019 by Ian Sterling 14 Comments

Agitated water stirring and churning around

It definitely isn’t the most exciting part of owning an aquarium…

In fact, surface agitation is often overlooked, especially by beginners.

But that doesn’t change the fact that surface agitation is important!

So today, I am going to teach you everything you need to know about it!

Contents

  1. What is surface agitation?
  2. Why is surface agitation so important?
  3. Is there such a thing as too much surface agitation?
  4. How do you agitate the water in your aquarium?

What is surface agitation?

Have you ever seen a puddle of water that is so calm, still and smooth that it looks like a mirror?

Still surface of puddle of water reflecting surroundings no agitation

Yeah, like that…

Well, if you added nothing but water to your aquarium, that’s exactly what the surface would look like.

However, if you throw a stone or splash around in the puddle, the surface of the water would become rippled.

Jumping in puddle of water to agitate the surface

In aquariums, this movement of water on the surface of the tank is referred to as surface agitation.

It’s a boring and often forgotten aspect of aquariums, but surface agitation is important for most tanks.

Why is surface agitation so important?

The most compelling argument for surface agitation is self-explanatory…

It oxygenates your water!

As you are no doubt aware, the oxygen that your fish breath works its way down into your tank from the surface…

The bigger the surface area of the tank, the more oxygen can penetrate the water.

Now, ordinarily the water surface area is determined by the size of your aquarium.

A 4 ft x 2 ft aquarium, for example, has a lot more surface area than a small fish bowl.

However…

When you agitate the surface water in your tank, the layer of water that is in contact with the air is constantly changing – the agitation increases the surface area of your tank, even though the physical dimensions of your aquarium are unchanged.

Surface agitation promotes gas exchange – the agitation increases the rate at which oxygen (O2) dissolves in water. It also increases the rate at which carbon dioxide (CO2) is released from the water.

The amount of oxygen in your aquarium plays a major role in determining how many fish you can keep in your tank.

You need enough oxygen to keep each fish alive! The more oxygen in the water, the more fish you can keep!

Surface agitation allows you to keep more fish in the same-size tank.

That’s a pretty convincing argument for surface agitation, huh?

Even if you are not planning on stocking any more fish, there is another added benefit of surface agitation…

It gets rid of that oily film that appears on the surface of still aquariums.

You know, that oil slick that begins to form?

Well, the reason it isn’t going anywhere is because there is no water movement.

Agitating the surface water will help break up the oily film.

Is there such a thing as too much surface agitation?

In most cases, the surface agitation caused by aquarium equipment won’t cause any problems.

However, there are two instances when strong surface movement actually works against you.

1. Your fish

It may surprise you to learn that some fish hate surface agitation or any other water movement.

One of those fish is the Betta splenden (Siamese fighting fish).

I know that many fish stores keep their betta in a tank with an air stone bubbling away, agitating the surface of the water. But this stresses the fish.

In their natural environment, betta live in rice paddies and marshes – water that is very still.

To keep your betta happy at home, you want to replicate the gentle water movement found in its natural habitat.

So, read up on the preferred water movement of your fish before adding any surface-agitating devices.

2. Planted tanks

Remember how I mentioned earlier that agitating the water also increases the rate at which CO2 exits the water?

Well, for planted tank owners who are injecting CO2 into the water, that isn’t necessarily a good thing – you want the CO2 to stay in the water, not leave it.

If you are injecting CO2 into your tank, you want to reduce agitation down to a gentle ripple – so that you are not wasting CO2.

How do you agitate the water in your aquarium?

So, you have decided you want to agitate the surface water of your aquarium.

Here are four simple devices that will do just that!

1. Filter

Hang on back hob filter agitating the surface water of aquarium

If your tank already has a filter set up, then you will most likely have everything you need to agitate the surface of your aquarium already.

Hang on back (HOB) filters and under gravel filters both have return lines that cause water movement at the surface of the aquarium, agitating the water.

For canister filters, you need to point the return up towards the surface of the water to agitate it.

Sponge filters use either an airstone or air line to operate. As the bubbles rise to the surface, they agitate the water.

2. Aquarium bubbler

Aquarium airstone bubbler with air line tube on black background in water

Commonly used by beginners and owners of small tanks, aquarium bubblers offer an affordable means to agitate the surface of your tank.

Simply hook the bubbler up to an good aquarium air pump and insert it into your tank. The bubbler will produce hundreds of tiny little bubbles. As the bubbles rise, they churn the surface of the water.

Popular types of aquarium bubblers include airstones and bubble walls.

3. Power head

Powerhead agitating the surface water in fish tank

A powerhead is essentially a submersible pump that is placed inside your aquarium to boost the water movement.

Water is drawn in through the bottom of the unit and out the top. As the water flows from the return, it stirs the surface of the water.

4. Wavemaker

Wavemaker circulating fan in aquarium agitating water

Essentially a circulating fan, a wavemaker is positioned inside your tank and recreates the water movement of naturally occurring waves in the ocean.

By aiming the fan upwards, the wavemaker is more than capable of agitating the surface water.

5. Spray bar

Aquarium spray bar feeding water onto surface

In its simplest form, a spray bar is little more than a piece of pipe with holes in it.

A spray bar sits on your filter outlet and disperses the water evenly and gently across the surface of your aquarium.

6. Lily pipe

Glass lily pipe outflow sitting inside planted tank
Source

A lily pipe is a flower-shaped glass pipe that sits on the outflow of your aquarium filter.

As water flows through the pipe, it disperses water across the surface of your aquarium, agitating it. Lily pipes that are specifically designed to agitate the surface water are called poppy pipes.

Conclusion

It may not be the most exciting thing you will read about aquariums today, but surface agitation is an important part of fish keeping.

Do you agitate the surface of your aquarium? Let me know your preferred method in the comments below!

Related posts:

Aquarium Calculator: How Many Gallons Can Your Tank Hold?
What the Heck Is the Aquarium Water Column?
What the Heck Is Bioload and Why Is It Important to Your Aquarium?
Ian Sterling
Ian Sterling
I've been keeping fish for over 30 years and currently have 4 different aquariums – it's an addiction. I'm here to teach you everything there is to know about fishkeeping.

I also use this site as an excuse to spend lots of money on testing and reviewing different aquarium products! You can find my reviews here.

Comments

  1. ugur says

    January 14, 2019 at 5:37 am

    Hello, What about surface agitation in low tech tank tanks? It still gas offs the small amount of co2 or even increase the co2 level in tank?

    Reply
    • Ian Sterling says

      January 14, 2019 at 5:43 am

      Hi Ugur,

      Welcome to the balancing act that is co2. Ideally you would want enough flow that your water is moving to all corners of your tank and a film isn’t forming on the surface. It can take some trial and error, but you should eventually figure out the right amount for your tank so you are not ofgassing too much Co2

      Reply
  2. Chris g says

    January 10, 2019 at 3:43 am

    Hello. 65 gal cube. Corner flow, sump below and skimmer. I’ve been using 2 powerheads. I aimed one low and one at surface. However, after 2 years I view them as an annoyance. Visually…. I get my shimmer effect from my Kessil. My question. Is this .. I seem to acquire oxygen and gas exchange from my sump and skimmer, and the corner flow would seem to suck/drain surface film… If this is the case. Why point one at the surface? I’m thinking of removing both. And acquiring a cylinder style powerhead and hide it in the corner for the water movement… Your opinion would be appreciated. Thankyou

    Reply
    • Ian Sterling says

      January 10, 2019 at 4:31 am

      Hi Chris,

      This article was created with beginners in mind, those that just have an individual display tank. An open sump does indeed increase the amount of surface area that oxygen can be dissolved in. In your case you could remove both, however, in the days following, I would be closely monitoring your tank, testing daily, just to see what the effect of removal is. If it’s nothing, you are home clear.

      Reply
  3. Jon says

    November 13, 2018 at 8:25 am

    A Million thanks, Ian !

    Reply
    • Ian Sterling says

      November 13, 2018 at 9:01 am

      You’re welcome, Jon!

      Reply
  4. Dave says

    October 11, 2018 at 9:48 am

    I agree with the author. I see nothing negative about the reference to bubblers nor airstones.

    For my tank, however, I simply use extra plastic tubing from my canister filter to move the incoming water across the surface. It is a poor man’s substitute for a lily pipe or poppy pipe. I have the tubing at the water surface. It creates beautiful ripples across the entire tank. The main thing is that the water surface is always moving, mixing with air.

    Reply
    • Ian Sterling says

      October 11, 2018 at 10:23 am

      Hi Dave,

      That sounds like a great idea. Less breakable than a lily pipe too. Sometimes DIY solutions really are the best!

      Reply
      • Dave says

        October 13, 2018 at 11:28 am

        Hi Ian,

        Yeah, I know that some do not like the plastic tubes, but I don’t notice them.

        I have used airstones and UG filters in the past, but I don’t like the noise from the air pump. Later, I went to HOB filters, but I found that the biomedia is too small. I now have an Eheim Classic 350, on my 40 G Breeder, and it is great. No noise, good surface current, and my tank has remained stable for weeks–with no water changes. It holds three young fantail goldfish puppies, and some plants.

        I appreciate your article on surface agitation. Water ripples are necesary in tanks, as they are in nature.

        Thanks!

        Dave

        Reply
  5. Christina says

    September 14, 2018 at 8:55 am

    I find your dismissive regard for airstones to be bad advice. I’m sure your point was to have a tank with little fish but more plants and aquascaping. That’s not real fish keeping but preening b*******t.

    There are legitimate reasons for having airstones and a lot of fish enjoy the stream. Not to mention it’s nice to know that the fish he to breathe oxygen who don’t have a filter that hangs on the back.

    So stow your snobbery.

    Reply
    • Ian Sterling says

      September 14, 2018 at 9:13 am

      Hi Christina,

      I’m scratching my head on this one… Did we read the same article?

      If that was your takeaway from the article, then it would appear that you completely missed the point and have made yourself upset.

      I actually recommended bubblers, like airstones, as a way to provide water movement further down the guide.

      I merely suggested that an airstone is unsuitable for fish like betta, which prefer calm water. I stand behind this statement.

      Reply
      • Jason says

        October 25, 2018 at 12:41 am

        Christina sounds like she was having a bad day, or is just a total c**t. I’m going with the later.

        Thanks for your article Ian, it’s useful information.

        Reply
        • Ian Sterling says

          October 25, 2018 at 6:04 am

          Thanks Jason,

          You can’t please everyone 🙂

          Reply
  6. Jigar says

    May 30, 2018 at 9:39 pm

    Very helpful article helped me to solve my problem – no more oil on the surface.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your comment will appear after it is approved by our staff. For more information, please refer to our Comment Policy.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Links

  • About
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • DMCA Policy
  • Contact
  • Sponsors

Disclaimer

Content found on fishlab.com is for informational purposes only and is not intended to be a substitute for professional veterinarian advice.

Click here to read the full disclaimer.

Our #1 Sponsor

Want the best products tested by real dogs? Check out doglab.

Our favorite article: Best Slow Feed Dog Bowl.

Please note – despite a similarity in website names, our relationship with doglab ends with their sponsorship, which helps fund our product reviews. We are not affiliated with doglab, all opinions and content found on doglab.com are their own and do not necessarily reflect that of fishlab.com

© FishLab 2019 - All Rights Reserved